|
The obvious reaction could well be to think that it is easy to tell red wine from white?
Okay now try it blind folded sometime and holding your nose as well.
Some white-wine drinkers who rarely
sample red could be convinced that the differences
between the types are quite deep
yet very fundamental.
Consider the stereotypes: White wine is light, fruity and refreshing, an
anonymous tipple for casual sipping. Red wine is stronger, complicated and
although fine for connoisseurs, perhaps much harder to get to know.
Do these stereotypes have validity?
Or are the differences overshadowed by the similarities between what are,
after all, beverages made from fruit as closely related as red (or blue or
purple) and white (or green or golden) grapes?
Prompted by a recent discussion
on the subject among several colleagues
communicating with personal computers on an online Wine Forum. The decision
was made to find out by indulging
in the practice of
"blind" tasting to its logical extreme.
A point being was to ensure that any objectivity is unmarred by prejudice or
a preconceived idea . It's very easy to be objective if one does not know which
glass contains the $20 boutique wine and which holds the $2.99 jug variety.
It's easy enough to arrange this kind of tasting: All you need is someone
to pour the wine. It doesn't matter if you see what's in the glass.
It will be a little more complicated trying to compare red and white without looking, as
a real, if though, temporary loss of vision is required. Something
that can be achieved by asking a colleague to wrap a bandanna over the eyes
and around head.
As an example try the following:
Use four moderately priced wines - Say two white and two red - for this simple test.
A suggestion would be, two California wines - a red 1981 Inglenook Vineyards, Napa Valley,
Petite Sirah ($5.49) and a white 1985 Gundlach Bundschu, Sonoma County (Rhinefarm
Vineyards) Gewurztraminer ($6.49) - anticipating that these two wines would
display marked characteristics that should be rather easy to identify.
To add a little complexity one could add a white 1985 Collavini Grave del Friuli,
Pinot Grigio, from Italy ($5.79) and a red 1983 Premiat Dealul Mare, Cabernet
Sauvignon, from Romania ($2.99), expecting them to be rather simple, yet
fruity wines that might be more difficult to distinguish without having the
benefit of being able to see them.
Differences will definitely exist, but they're more subtle than you might expect.
one will fairly easily tell the red from the white, but that could be a
little more challenging without having benefited from a number of years' tasting
experience. As it will be, it will not be easy pegging all four wines to their
specific labels.
Use this summary as a helping guide during the
blind tasting.
Glass No. 1 (the Petite Sirah) should be easy. There will be aroma's of green olives and
black pepper and then the mouth-filling, fruity and acidic flavor which will give away the grape
variety in this nature of a gutsy, full-flavored wine, it will be the best of the
four that are going to be and that can be obtained at such a
bargain price.
Dry acidity and a hint of oak will be the tell-tale signs that Glass No.
3 (the Romanian Cabernet) will hold over the other red wine.
The two remaining glasses will be the whites and could very well be
misidentified.
Glass No. 2 will obviously be white. It could well pass for an inexpensive
Rhine wine with a soft, faintly sweet taste. It will have a musky aroma, reminiscent of
an overripe cantaloupe melon, this wouldn't be surprising if found in a
Gewurztraminer, but the wine will prove to be the Pinot Grigio.
A citrus quality with a faint bitter after taste will clearly be
experienced in Glass No. 4 which will also be a white, but, will be misleading because of the wine's
natural musk, failure to
recognize this wine as "Gewurz;" will not be uncommon for it will lack
the exuberantly spicy quality typical from such a flavorful grape in Europe.
Hopefully this suggested and hopefully useful exercise, will allow people
to salvage their ego by correctly identifying all the red and white wines in
this scenario. |